Zappa Mexico X 64 Versus Human being 2007

[Father]

Zappa Mexico X64: 11.4 ply; 1.136kN/s AMD Athlon(tm) 64 X2 Dual Core Processor 4600+ 2403MHz, (2 threads)

Human being 1
Zappa Mexico 0

Top Machines can be losing in 2007, playimg against human beings

[Event "Partida evaluada, 5m + 0s"]
[Site "Sala de máquinas"]
[Date "2007.09.27"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Father"]
[Black "Fernspiel"]
[Result "1-0"]
[ECO "D00"]
[WhiteElo "2062"]
[BlackElo "2529"]
[Annotator "Restrepo,Pablo"]
[PlyCount "459"]
[EventDate "2007.09.27"]
[WhiteTeam "Zappa Mexico X64: 11.4 ply; 1.136kN/s AMD Ath"]
[TimeControl "300"]

1. d4 {1} d5 {B/0 0} 2. a3 {2} Nf6 {B/0 0} 3. c3 {1} Nc6 {B/0 0} 4. f4 {1} Bf5
{B/0 0} 5. Nf3 {2} e6 {B/0 0} 6. e3 {1} Bd6 {B/0 0} 7. Bd3 {1} O-O {B/0 0} 8.
O-O {1} Qd7 {B/0 0} 9. Qc2 {1} a6 {-0.33/11 13} 10. Re1 {(Nbd2) 3} Ne7 {
-0.44/11 5} 11. Nbd2 {1} c5 {-0.38/11 4} 12. Nf1 {(e4) 2} Bxd3 {-0.74/12 8} 13.
Qxd3 {1} Nf5 {-0.73/12 5} 14. g3 {(dxc5) 2} h5 {-0.93/10 6} 15. h4 {(N1d2) 4}
Rfd8 {-1.44/11 10} 16. Re2 {(Ng5) 1} Ne4 {-1.52/10 6} 17. Rg2 {(Ng5) 1} Be7 {
-1.40/11 14} 18. N3d2 {(Qe2) 1} Qc6 {-1.40/12 8} 19. Qe2 {2} Nf6 {-1.35/12 3}
20. Kh2 {(Nf3) 1} Rac8 {-1.45/11 5} 21. Kg1 {(Nf3) 0} g6 {-1.37/12 7} 22. Nf3 {
(Nh2) 1} Ne4 {-1.32/11 7} 23. N3d2 {(g4) 2} Kg7 {-1.53/11 5} 24. Qd3 {(Nxe4) 2}
b6 {-1.54/11 5} 25. Kh2 {(Qe2) 3} c4 {-1.56/10 8} 26. Qe2 {2} Nf6 {-1.55/11 1}
27. Nf3 {1} Qb7 {-1.41/11 3} 28. Kg1 {(Ne5) 1} Ne4 {-1.37/12 7} 29. Bd2 {
(Kh2) 1} Nf6 {8} 30. Be1 {-1.35/9 0} Qc7 {6} 31. Rc1 {(Ne5) -1.18/10 0} Qc6 {5}
32. Rc2 {(Ne5) -1.26/10 0} Qa4 {4} 33. Kh2 {(Ne5) -1.40/11 0} Ne4 {6} 34. Kg1 {
(Ng5) -1.56/11 0} Rh8 {4} 35. Kh2 {(Ng5) -1.43/11 0} a5 {4} 36. Kg1 {
(Ng5) -1.62/10 0} Qb3 {3} 37. Kh2 {(Ng5) -1.49/10 0} Rce8 {-1.62/10 3} 38. Kg1
{(Ng5) 1} Rd8 {3} 39. Kh2 {(N1h2) -1.45/10 0} Qa4 {4} 40. Kg1 {-1.51/10 0} Rde8
{3} 41. Kh2 {(N1h2) -1.43/11 0} Rh7 {3} 42. Kg1 {-1.54/10 0} f6 {4} 43. Kh2 {
(Qd1) -1.28/11 0} Rc8 {-1.54/9 3} 44. Qd1 {(Kg1) 4} Rhh8 {-1.38/10 3} 45. Qc1 {
(N3d2) 1} Kh7 {-1.37/9 3} 46. N3d2 {(g4) 3} Ned6 {-1.21/11 3} 47. Nf3 {(g4) 2}
Nh6 {-1.17/12 5} 48. Kg1 {(Rce2) 1} Qc6 {-1.17/10 6} 49. Rce2 {1} Ne4 {
-1.05/10 2} 50. Qc2 {(N3d2) 1} Kg7 {-1.05/11 3} 51. N3d2 {(N1d2) 1} b5 {
-1.01/12 5} 52. Nxe4 {(Nh2) 1} dxe4 {-1.13/7 0} 53. Nd2 {(Nh2) 1} f5 {
-1.35/12 3} 54. Nf1 {0} Ng4 {-1.40/13 4} 55. Kh1 {(Rd2) 1} Nf6 {-1.38/12 3} 56.
Qc1 {(Bf2) 0} Nd5 {-1.41/13 2} 57. Rc2 {(Rd2) 2} Rhd8 {-1.41/13 1} 58. Kg1 {
(Rcd2) 1} Kh7 {-1.42/12 2} 59. Kh2 {(Kh1) 0} Ra8 {-1.41/11 1} 60. Kg1 {0} Rdb8
{-1.41/12 1} 61. Kh2 {(Kh1) 0} Kh8 {-1.41/12 2} 62. Kg1 {(Kh1) 0} Qd7 {
-1.41/13 1} 63. Kh2 {0} Rd8 {-1.41/13 1} 64. Kg1 {(Kh1) 0} Rab8 {-1.41/14 2}
65. Kh2 {(Rcd2) 0} Nf6 {-1.41/12 2} 66. Kg1 {0} Kg7 {-1.41/12 0} 67. Kh1 {
(Rcd2) 1} Nd5 {-1.41/12 2} 68. Kg1 {(Rcd2) 0} Kh8 {-1.41/14 1} 69. Kh1 {
(Rcd2) 0} Rbc8 {-1.41/13 1} 70. Kg1 {0} Kg7 {-1.41/13 0} 71. Kh1 {(Qd2) 0} Qc6
{-1.41/14 2} 72. Kg1 {0} Kh7 {-1.41/14 0} 73. Kh2 {(Kh1) 0} Qb6 {-1.41/13 2}
74. Kg1 {(Kh1) 0} Qd6 {-1.41/14 1} 75. Kh2 {(Kh1) 0} Rb8 {-1.41/13 1} 76. Kh1 {
(Rcd2) 0} Qd7 {-1.41/14 1} 77. Kg1 {0} Ra8 {-1.41/14 0} 78. Kh1 {(Rcd2) 0} Rac8
{-1.41/14 1} 79. Kg1 {0} Kh8 {-1.41/14 0} 80. Kh1 {1} Qc6 {-1.41/14 0} 81. Kg1
{(Kh2) 0} Qd7 {-1.41/14 1} 82. Kh1 {1} Kh7 {-1.41/15 0} 83. Kg1 {0} Ra8 {
-1.41/15 0} 84. Kh2 {(Rcd2) 0} Kh8 {-1.41/13 1} 85. Kg1 {(Kh1) 0} Rdc8 {
-1.41/14 1} 86. Kh2 {0} Qc7 {-1.41/14 0} 87. Kg1 {(Kh1) 0} Rab8 {-1.41/14 1}
88. Kh1 {0} Rd8 {-1.41/14 0} 89. Kg1 {(Rcd2) 1} Qd6 {-1.41/13 1} 90. Kh1 {
(Rce2) 0} Kg7 {-1.41/14 1} 91. Kg1 {(Rcd2) 0} Kh8 {-1.41/12 1} 92. Kh1 {
(Rce2) 0} Kg7 {-1.41/15 1} 93. Kg1 {(Rcd2) 0} Kf7 {-1.40/11 1} 94. Kh1 {
(Rcd2) 0} Qc7 {-1.41/11 1} 95. Kg1 {(Rcd2) 0} Nf6 {-1.44/10 2} 96. Kh1 {
(Rcd2) 1} Qb6 {-1.41/9 1} 97. Kg1 {(Rcd2) 1} Kg7 {-1.42/9 2} 98. Kh1 {(Rcd2) 0}
Qd6 {-1.41/9 1} 99. Kh2 {(Rcd2) 0} Qd5 {-1.41/9 2} 100. Kh1 {0} a4 {-1.41/12 0}
101. Kh2 {(Rcd2) 1} Qb7 {-1.41/10 0} 102. Kh1 {0} Rbc8 {-1.41/13 0} 103. Rce2 {
1} Qd7 {-1.38/11 0} 104. Qc2 {1} Qc6 {-1.37/12 0} 105. Kh2 {(Bf2) 1} Rb8 {
-1.37/9 1} 106. Kg1 {(Kh1) 0} Kf7 {-1.38/10 1} 107. Kh2 {(Kh1) 0} Nd5 {
-1.37/10 1} 108. Kg1 {(Kh1) 1} Rbc8 {-1.37/10 0} 109. Kh1 {0} Rb8 {-1.36/10 0}
110. Kh2 {(Bf2) 0} Kg7 {-1.37/11 0} 111. Kh1 {0} Kh8 {-1.37/12 0} 112. Kh2 {
(Rd2) 0} Qe8 {-1.37/10 1} 113. Kh1 {(Rd2) 0} Kh7 {-1.37/12 0} 114. Kh2 {(Rd2) 0
} Qf7 {-1.37/10 0} 115. Kh1 {0} Nf6 {-1.37/11 1} 116. Rh2 {(Bf2) 1} Kh8 {
-1.37/9 1} 117. Kg1 {(Rhg2) 1} Rd7 {-1.38/9 0} 118. Kh1 {(Rhg2) 0} Ng4 {
-1.38/10 0} 119. Ref2 {(Rhg2) 2} Nxh2 {-1.78/10 0} 120. Rxh2 {1} Kg7 {
-1.80/11 0} 121. Kg1 {(Rd2) 1} Bd6 {-1.67/10 1} 122. Kh1 {(Kf2) 0} Rdd8 {
-1.89/10 0} 123. Kg1 {(Rg2) 0} Qb7 {-1.76/10 0} 124. Kh1 {(Kf2) 0} Kf8 {
-1.74/11 0} 125. Kg1 {0} Qd5 {-1.72/11 0} 126. Kh1 {(Kf2) 1} Be7 {-1.90/11 0}
127. Kg1 {(Rd2) 0} Rd7 {-1.73/10 0} 128. Kh1 {(Kf2) 1} Bf6 {-1.93/10 0} 129.
Kg1 {0} Rc8 {-1.76/11 0} 130. Kh1 {(Kf2) 0} Rcc7 {-1.93/10 0} 131. Kg1 {(Rg2) 0
} Rg7 {-1.75/10 1} 132. Kh1 {(Kf2) 0} Rc8 {-1.84/10 0} 133. Kg1 {0} Rd8 {
-1.82/11 0} 134. Kh1 {(Kf2) 1} Kg8 {-1.90/9 0} 135. Kg1 {(Rd2) 0} Rgd7 {
-1.76/10 1} 136. Kh1 {(Kf2) 0} Be7 {-1.90/10 0} 137. Kg1 {(Rd2) 0} Kg7 {
-1.87/8 0} 138. Kh1 {(Kf2) 0} Bf6 {-1.89/10 0} 139. Kg1 {0} Kg8 {-1.79/11 0}
140. Kh1 {(Kf2) 0} Rd6 {-1.88/9 0} 141. Kg1 {0} R8d7 {-1.73/11 0} 142. Kh1 {
(Kf2) 0} Rb6 {-1.90/9 0} 143. Kg1 {(Rd2) 0} Rb8 {-1.71/9 0} 144. Kh1 {(Kf2) 0}
Rc8 {-1.87/9 0} 145. Kg1 {0} Be7 {-1.74/11 0} 146. Kh1 {(Kf2) 0} Kf8 {
-1.90/10 0} 147. Kg1 {(Rd2) 0} Rcd8 {-1.74/9 0} 148. Kh1 {(Kf2) 0} Re8 {
-1.89/9 0} 149. Kg1 {0} Bf6 {-1.71/12 0} 150. Kh1 {(Kf2) 0} Rb7 {-1.90/7 0}
151. Kg1 {(Rd2) 0} Rbb8 {-1.85/7 0} 152. Kh1 {(Kf2) 0} Rec8 {-1.90/8 0} 153.
Kg1 {(Rd2) 0} Be7 {-1.83/6 0} 154. Kh1 {(Kf2) 0} Rb7 {-1.91/7 0} 155. Kg1 {
(Rd2) 0} Rd8 {-1.87/6 0} 156. Kh1 {(Kf2) 0} Bf6 {-1.90/7 0} 157. Kg1 {(Rd2) 0}
Qd6 {-1.89/6 0} 158. Kh1 {(Qd2) 0} Rf7 {-1.93/7 0} 159. Kg1 {0} Qd5 {-1.72/9 0}
160. Kh1 {0} Qd6 {-1.93/7 0} 161. Kg1 {0} Kg7 {-1.77/9 0} 162. Kh1 {(Kf2) 0}
Rfd7 {-1.95/6 0} 163. Kg1 {(Rd2) 0} Kf8 {-1.92/7 0} 164. Kh1 {(Rd2) 0} Qd5 {
-1.93/7 0} 165. Kg1 {(Rd2) 0} Rf7 {-1.92/7 0} 166. Kh1 {(Rd2) 0} Rc8 {-1.93/7 0
} 167. Kg1 {(Rd2) 1} Rcc7 {-1.70/7 0} 168. Kh1 {(Rd2) 0} Ra7 {-1.23/6 0} 169.
Kg1 {(Nd2) 0} b4 {-1.17/6 0} 170. cxb4 {2} Rfc7 {-0.71/10 0} 171. Bc3 {(Nd2) 1}
Rc8 {-1.14/6 0} 172. Qd2 {(Nd2) 0} Rca8 {-1.11/7 0} 173. Rf2 {(Qc2) 1} Rc7 {
-1.17/6 0} 174. Kh2 {(Rh2) 0} Raa7 {-1.14/7 0} 175. Kh3 {(Qe1) 0} Rc8 {
-1.16/6 0} 176. Kh2 {0} Rcc7 {-1.06/14 0} 177. Kg1 {(Qe1) 0} Rf7 {-1.07/7 0}
178. Kh2 {(Qe1) 1} Qb5 {-1.06/6 0} 179. Kg1 {(Qe2) 1} Rac7 {-1.07/7 0} 180. Qe1
{0} Qd5 {-1.06/13 0} 181. Nd2 {(Kh2) 1} Qb5 {-1.06/10 0} 182. Nb1 {(Kh2) 0}
Rcd7 {-0.89/5 0} 183. Kh2 {(Bd2) 0} Qc6 {0} 184. Kh1 {(Qe2) -0.80/8 0} Be7 {0}
185. Kg1 {(Nd2) -0.97/6 0} Bd6 {-0.91/6 0} 186. Kh1 {1} Rd8 {-0.69/11 0} 187.
Kg1 {(Qe2) 0} Qd5 {0} 188. Kh1 {(Qd1) -1.04/6 0} Rc8 {-0.77/6 0} 189. Kg1 {
(Qd1) 0} Qc6 {-0.80/7 0} 190. Qf1 {(Qd1) 1} Rb8 {-0.75/7 0} 191. Qg2 {(Rc2) 2}
Rc8 {-0.82/7 0} 192. Qh2 {(Rc2) 0} Bc7 {-0.85/6 0} 193. Rg2 {(Rc2) 0} Bd8 {
-0.77/8 0} 194. Kf1 {(Rc2) 0} Qb5 {-0.98/6 0} 195. Rg1 {(Rc2) 2} Bf6 {-1.15/6 0
} 196. Rh1 {(Ke1) 1} Qd5 {-1.18/5 0} 197. Qf2 {(Qc2) 1} Ra7 {-1.10/6 0} 198.
Kg1 {(Qc2) 0} Rcc7 {-1.16/5 0} 199. Rh2 {(Kh2) 0} Ra6 {-0.96/6 0} 200. Rh3 {
(b5) 1} Ra8 {-1.08/6 0} 201. Rh2 {1} Qc6 {-0.69/12 0} 202. Rh1 {(Qc2) 0} Rd8 {
-0.99/7 0} 203. Bd2 {(Rh2) 2} Ra8 {-0.88/5 0} 204. Nc3 {(Kh2) 0} Re7 {-0.67/7 0
} 205. Be1 {(Kh2) 1} Qd7 {-0.68/6 0} 206. Qe2 {(Rh2) 1} Ree8 {-0.65/6 0} 207.
Bf2 {(Rh2) 0} Rec8 {-0.83/6 0} 208. Kg2 {(Kh2) 1} Ra7 {-0.83/6 0} 209. Rh2 {
(Rd1) 0} Qc6 {-0.87/5 0} 210. Bg1 {(Rh1) 0} Rcc7 {-0.89/5 0} 211. Qc2 {(Kf1) 1}
Rh7 {-0.84/5 0} 212. Kf1 {1} Rhc7 {-0.67/11 0} 213. Re2 {(Bf2) 1} Rc8 {
-0.79/5 0} 214. Bf2 {(Ke1) 1} Rcc7 {-0.75/5 0} 215. Kg1 {(Be1) 0} Qe8 {
-0.77/5 0} 216. b5 {(Be1) 2} Rcb7 {-0.77/5 0} 217. Re1 {(Nxa4) 1} Qd7 {
-0.84/5 0} 218. Ra1 {(Nxa4) 0} Rb8 {-0.85/4 0} 219. Ra2 {(Be1) 0} Rba8 {
-0.89/4 0} 220. Kh2 {(Be1) 1} Qc7 {-0.89/5 0} 221. Be1 {(Ra1) 0} Bd8 {-0.73/6 0
} 222. Kg1 {(Ra1) 1} Qb7 {-0.86/6 0} 223. Bd2 {(Ra1) 1} Ba5 {-1.06/6 0} 224.
Kf2 {(Ra1) 4} Rc8 {-1.27/4 0} 225. Ke1 {(b6) 1} Qd7 {-1.33/4 0} 226. Ra1 {
(b6) 1} Rb8 {-0.98/6 0} 227. Ra2 {(Nxa4) 1} Rbb7 {-1.43/5 0} 228. Ke2 {(Nxa4) 4
} Qe8 {-1.16/6 0} 229. Kf2 {(Nxa4) 2} Ra8 {-1.33/4 0} 230. Nb1 {
(b6) Time (Lag: Av=0.82s, max=3.2s) 2} 1-0

r3qk2/1r6/4p1p1/bP3p1p/p1pPpP1P/P3P1P1/RPQB1K2/1N6 b - - 0 230

[Sebastian Boehme]

This is always the same:

Father sets up the stonewall - engines sometimes can not break through and thus their major weakness becomes visible: trying to crush a solid pawn chain....

CG to Father on the many games he won in this way, although I find these games very boring and not fun too watch. But: it is efficient and thats what counts?

Regards,
Sebastian

[Terry McCracken]

This is always the same:

Father sets up the stonewall - engines sometimes can not break through and thus their major weakness becomes visible: trying to crush a solid pawn chain....

CG to Father on the many games he won in this way, although I find these games very boring and not fun too watch. But: it is efficient and thats what counts?

Regards,
Sebastian

What counts is programmers must resolve this problem....when they do, Father can't bore us to death

Best,
Terry

[Father]

Hello Sebastiam and Terry.
In my humbble opinion, I belive, that programers are in a strong problem or puzzle in chess programation.
Everybody knows the solution, but the solution by itself is a mistake, becouse all engines that will be using the solution, will be leaving their level one and going to level two.
In other way........ If the solution will be instaled, our human being brain will be searching for new kind of holes in the wall.
The combat has not ended.
With best respect,
Pablo

[Terry McCracken]

Hello Sebastiam and Terry.
In my humbble opinion, I belive, that programers are in a strong problem or puzzle in chess programation.
Everybody knows the solution, but the solution by itself is a mistake, becouse all engines that will be using the solution, will be leaving their level one and going to level two.
In other way........ If the solution will be instaled, our human being brain will be searching for new kind of holes in the wall.
The combat has not ended.
With best respect,
Pablo

I for one will be glad to see all forms of anti-computer techniques rendered useless.

Terry

[Dylan Sharp]

What counts is programmers must resolve this problem....when they do, Father can't bore us to death

Chess Tiger has an "anti-human" personality that wont let the human make such positions, and you can ask Father, he couldn't even draw against it...

[Peter Grayson]

If the posted game had occurred in a tournament, wouldn't the adjudicator or controller have declared the game a draw on the basis that White was not trying to win? So really the game was a draw as there is no evidence that White made any attempt to win.
PeterG

[Father]

Peter.
I dont know the answer to the question but what I know perfectly,
is the subjetive evaluation, about that I have ever trying to beat chess machines...sure I was across the "antichess" technique.
Regards,
Pablo Ignacio Restrepo

[Terry McCracken]

What counts is programmers must resolve this problem....when they do, Father can't bore us to death

Chess Tiger has an "anti-human" personality that wont let the human make such positions, and you can ask Father, he couldn't even draw against it...

Tiger, Rebel, Crafty et al have code to open the position or to try and prevent the human from closing it, it isn't perfect by no means.

The problem hasn't been resolved. I've seen Tiger "Stonewalled" by human players.

[Dylan Sharp]

I've seen Tiger "Stonewalled" by human players.

Have you seen the special Tiger anti-human setting being stonewalled? The programmer took extra measures to avoid this, such as sacrificing a knight to keep the position open, and I remember not even Father could succeed against it.

[Father]

Does have Tiger 15 Antihuman Setting an Akiles element?

Yes it has an akiles element too, as all chess computer machines.
Antichess is a general antilogarithm, and here,
and example, of a "blind Tiger in midle of
its two Noises.

Best regards,

Pablo Restrepo
Father

[Event "Partida evaluada, 3m + 0s"]
[Site "Sala de máquinas"]
[Date "2007.10.01"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Father"]
[Black "HydraAssasin"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "A43"]
[WhiteElo "2062"]
[BlackElo "2623"]
[Annotator "Restrepo,Pablo"]
[PlyCount "34"]
[EventDate "2007.10.01"]
[BlackTeam "Einladung zum Simultan von Booker25800 im Rau"]
[TimeControl "180"]

1. c3 {3} c5 {0} 2. d4 {5} e6 {0} 3. e3 {4} b6 {0.02/11 3} 4. f4 {2} Qh4+ {
-0.26/11 5} 5. g3 {4} Qf6 {-0.04/13 4} 6. Nf3 {1} Bb7 {-0.04/12 6} 7. Bg2 {1}
cxd4 {-0.02/12 4} 8. exd4 {2} d5 {0.32/11 0} 9. O-O {1} Bd6 {0.60/11 3} 10. Re1
{1} Ne7 {0.38/12 5} 11. Ne5 {1} O-O {0.32/11 3} 12. Nd2 {2} Rd8 {0.42/10 4} 13.
Ndf3 {1} h6 {0.56/11 5} 14. Re2 {2} Ba6 {0.15/11 2} 15. Re1 {2} Bb7 {0.15/14 0}
16. Re2 {1} Ba6 {0.15/11 2} 17. Re1 {1} Bb7 {
(Lag: Av=0.47s, max=0.6s) 0.15/14 1} 1/2-1/2

rn1r2k1/pb2npp1/1p1bpq1p/3pN3/3P1P2/2P2NP1/PP4BP/R1BQR1K1 w - - 0 18

[Dylan Sharp]

I don't consider it a full anti-human if it didn't have the contempt adjusted properly.

[Terry McCracken]

I don't consider it a full anti-human if it didn't have the contempt adjusted properly.

The point is all programs can be locked down, with pawn blockades, no matter what the settings are.

[Dylan Sharp]

Yes, my point is that this personality is supposed to break through those blockades, even sacrificing pieces if necessary. If this personality is unable to do what it claimed to do, then I'm obviously wrong, but I don't consider the game Father posted as proof (he drew by 3 fold repetition and that's unrelated).

[Father]

MAN VERSUS MACHINE
OCTUBER 2 2007
ZAPPA MEXICO 2007 VERSUS FATHER


[Event "Partida evaluada, 3m + 0s"]
[Site "Sala de máquinas"]
[Date "2007.10.02"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Meldan"]
[Black "Father"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "A84"]
[WhiteElo "2516"]
[BlackElo "2062"]
[Annotator "Restrepo,Pablo"]
[PlyCount "536"]
[EventDate "2007.10.02"]
[WhiteTeam "Zappa Mexico: 14.0 ply; 588kN/s AMD Athlon(tm"]
[TimeControl "180"]

1. d4 {B/0 0} d5 {1} 2. c4 {B/0 0} e6 {0} 3. Nc3 {B/0 0} c6 {1} 4. Nf3 {B/0 0}
f5 {1} 5. Bf4 {B/0 0} Nf6 {1} 6. e3 {B/0 0} Bd6 {0} 7. Bd3 {B/0 0} O-O {1} 8.
O-O {B/0 0} Qc7 {1} 9. Bxd6 {6} Qxd6 {0.64/10 0} 10. Qc2 {0.58/11 4} g6 {
(Ne4) 1} 11. Rfd1 {0.79/10 5} Re8 {(Nbd7) 1} 12. Ne2 {0.78/10 5} Nbd7 {1} 13.
Nf4 {0.90/10 2} Nf8 {(e5) 1} 14. Rac1 {1.07/10 5} a6 {(dxc4) 0} 15. h4 {
1.14/9 4} h5 {(N8d7) 1} 16. Be2 {1.64/9 3} Kg7 {(Ng4) 0} 17. Ne5 {1.58/9 3} Bd7
{(N6d7) 2} 18. Qb3 {1.78/10 21} Reb8 {(dxc4) 2} 19. Qd3 {1.73/8 4} Be8 {
(dxc4) 1} 20. g3 {1.57/9 4} Ra7 {(dxc4) 1} 21. Qb3 {1.59/8 4} Raa8 {(N6d7) 1}
22. c5 {1.65/9 4} Qe7 {2} 23. Qb6 {1.49/10 0} Qd8 {(Ng4) 7} 24. Qb4 {1.35/10 4}
Qe7 {(a5) 1} 25. Qa5 {1.47/10 4} Qd8 {1} 26. Qc3 {1.31/10 1} Qe7 {1} 27. Qa5 {
1.38/10 3} Qd8 {1} 28. Qc3 {1.33/10 1} Qe7 {1} 29. Bd3 {1.29/10 3} Ra7 {
(N8d7) 1} 30. Qa5 {1.55/9 3} Raa8 {(Ng4) 1} 31. f3 {1.55/10 6} Qd8 {(N8d7) 0}
32. Qd2 {1.30/10 2} Qe7 {(N6d7) 5} 33. Kh1 {1.35/8 2} N6d7 {(N8d7) 1} 34. Qa5 {
1.22/9 2} Nxe5 {2} 35. dxe5 {1.06/10 1} Qd8 {(Kg8) 10} 36. Qb4 {1.07/10 3} Qc7
{(Bf7) 1} 37. Qc3 {0.97/11 3} Bf7 {1} 38. Be2 {0.94/10 4} Nd7 {1} 39. Nd3 {
0.87/11 0} Rg8 {(b6) 2} 40. Qd4 {0.97/10 2} Kh7 {(Kh8) 1} 41. f4 {0.93/10 2}
Kg7 {(Rgb8) 2} 42. b3 {0.96/10 2} Rgb8 {1} 43. Rd2 {0.96/11 1} Nf8 {(a5) 0} 44.
Ne1 {1.07/10 1} Be8 {(Nd7) 0} 45. Nf3 {1.19/10 2} Ra7 {(b5) 1} 46. Ng5 {
1.25/9 2} Rd8 {(Bf7) 3} 47. Rc4 {1.31/8 2} Rd7 {(Bf7) 1} 48. Rb4 {1.35/10 1}
Re7 {(Bf7) 1} 49. Bf1 {1.39/10 1} Ra8 {(Nh7) 1} 50. Rc2 {1.32/10 2} Rc8 {
(Kg8) 1} 51. a3 {1.42/9 2} Qd8 {(Nh7) 1} 52. Rb6 {1.39/9 3} Rcc7 {(Qc7) 1} 53.
Qc3 {1.54/9 1} Qa8 {(Rcd7) 1} 54. Qa5 {1.54/9 1} Qa7 {(Rcd7) 1} 55. Kh2 {
1.52/9 3} Qa8 {(Rcd7) 1} 56. Nf3 {1.51/9 1} Qc8 {(Rcd7) 1} 57. Rd2 {1.49/10 1}
Kh7 {(Rcd7) 1} 58. Rd1 {1.47/10 1} Kg7 {(Kh8) 0} 59. Be2 {1.53/10 1} Kh8 {
(Rcd7) 1} 60. Kg2 {1.52/11 2} Kg7 {(Rcd7) 0} 61. Nd4 {1.51/10 1} Kh8 {(Rcd7) 1}
62. Kh1 {1.51/10 1} Kg7 {(Kg8) 0} 63. Kh2 {1.51/8 0} Kh8 {(Rcd7) 0} 64. Bf1 {
1.49/10 1} Kg7 {(Bf7) 0} 65. Kg1 {1.51/9 0} Kh8 {1} 66. Be2 {1.51/10 0} Kg7 {
(Kg8) 0} 67. Kf2 {1.51/9 1} Kh8 {(Rcd7) 0} 68. Kg1 {1.50/9 1} Kg7 {(Kg8) 0} 69.
Kh1 {1.51/10 1} Kh8 {(Kg8) 0} 70. Rb4 {1.51/10 0} Kg7 {(Rcd7) 0} 71. Nf3 {
1.50/8 0} Kh8 {(Kg8) 1} 72. Nd4 {1.50/11 0} Kg7 {(Rcd7) 1} 73. Kg1 {1.50/10 0}
Kh8 {(Kg8) 0} 74. Kf1 {1.50/10 0} Kg7 {(Kg8) 0} 75. Kf2 {1.50/10 0} Kh8 {
(Kg8) 0} 76. Rd2 {1.48/10 0} Kg7 {(Rcd7) 0} 77. Kg1 {1.50/9 0} Kh8 {(Kg8) 0}
78. Kh1 {1.49/9 0} Kg7 {(Rcd7) 0} 79. Rd1 {1.51/9 0} Kh8 {(Rcd7) 0} 80. Rb6 {
1.50/10 0} Kg7 {(Kg8) 1} 81. Kh2 {1.50/10 0} Kh7 {(Nd7) 0} 82. Kg2 {1.51/8 0}
Kg7 {(Kg8) 0} 83. Kf2 {1.50/9 0} Kh7 {(Kh8) 0} 84. Qc3 {1.50/8 0} Kg7 {(Kg8) 0}
85. Rb4 {1.51/8 1} Kh7 {(Kg8) 0} 86. Kg2 {1.50/8 0} Kg8 {(Rcd7) 0} 87. Rc1 {
1.49/9 0} Kh7 {(Rcd7) 0} 88. Kh1 {1.50/8 0} Kg8 {0} 89. Kg2 {1.49/10 0} Kh7 {
(Rcd7) 0} 90. Rd1 {1.48/9 0} Kg8 {(Rcd7) 0} 91. Qd2 {1.33/9 0} Kh7 {(Nd7) 0}
92. Nf3 {1.50/7 0} Kg8 {1} 93. Rc1 {1.46/9 0} Kg7 {(Rcd7) 0} 94. Nd4 {1.50/8 0}
Kg8 {1} 95. Kf2 {1.48/9 0} Kg7 {(Rcd7) 0} 96. Nf3 {1.50/7 0} Kg8 {1} 97. Nd4 {
1.47/10 0} Kg7 {(Rcd7) 0} 98. Nf3 {1.60/5 0} Kg8 {0} 99. Qd4 {1.30/9 0} Kg7 {
(Rcd7) 0} 100. Qc3 {1.25/8 0} Kg8 {0} 101. a4 {1.40/11 0} Kh7 {(a5) 0} 102. a5
{1.49/8 0} Kg8 {(Rcd7) 0} 103. Rd1 {1.48/9 0} Kh7 {(Rcd7) 0} 104. Nd4 {1.49/7 0
} Kg8 {(Rcd7) 1} 105. Kg2 {1.50/8 0} Kh7 {(Rcd7) 0} 106. Qa1 {1.49/8 0} Kg8 {
(Rcd7) 0} 107. Qb2 {1.49/8 0} Kh7 {(Rcd7) 0} 108. Qc3 {1.49/8 0} Kg8 {(Rcd7) 0}
109. Kf1 {1.48/9 0} Kh7 {(Rcd7) 0} 110. Qd3 {1.48/8 0} Kg8 {(Rcd7) 0} 111. Kf2
{1.48/9 0} Kh7 {(Rcd7) 0} 112. Qd2 {1.49/8 0} Kg8 {(Rcd7) 0} 113. Qa2 {1.49/8 0
} Rg7 {(Rcd7) 1} 114. Qa3 {1.48/8 0} Kh7 {(Rcd7) 0} 115. Kg2 {1.50/7 0} Kg8 {1}
116. Qa4 {1.46/10 0} Kh8 {(Rcd7) 0} 117. Kh1 {1.46/7 0} Kh7 {(Rcd7) 0} 118. Qa1
{1.47/7 0} Kh8 {(Rce7) 0} 119. Qc1 {1.46/8 0} Kh7 {(Rce7) 0} 120. Qc3 {1.46/7 0
} Kh8 {(Rce7) 0} 121. Kh2 {1.46/7 0} Kh7 {(Rce7) 0} 122. Kg2 {1.46/7 0} Kh8 {
(Rce7) 0} 123. Kf2 {1.46/7 0} Kh7 {(Rcd7) 0} 124. Rc1 {1.47/7 0} Kh8 {(Rce7) 1}
125. Qd2 {1.45/8 0} Kh7 {(Rce7) 0} 126. Rb6 {1.49/7 0} Kg8 {(Rcd7) 1} 127. Kg2
{1.49/7 0} Rh7 {(Rcd7) 0} 128. Qb4 {1.50/6 0} Rhe7 {(Rhg7) 0} 129. Qd2 {
1.48/8 0} Kh8 {(Rg7) 0} 130. Qc3 {1.48/7 0} Kg8 {(Rcd7) 0} 131. Kh1 {1.48/8 0}
Kh8 {(Rcd7) 1} 132. Rd1 {1.48/7 0} Kg8 {(Rcd7) 0} 133. Kh2 {1.48/8 0} Rh7 {
(Rcd7) 1} 134. Kh1 {1.49/7 0} Rhf7 {(Rhg7) 0} 135. Kg2 {1.47/8 0} Kh7 {(Rg7) 0}
136. Qc2 {1.57/6 0} Kg8 {(Rcd7) 1} 137. Kg1 {1.46/7 0} Kh7 {(Rcd7) 0} 138. Nf3
{1.52/7 0} Kg8 {(Kh8) 1} 139. Rb4 {1.47/7 0} Rg7 {(Rfe7) 2} 140. Kf2 {1.47/8 0}
Rgf7 {(Rce7) 1} 141. Qc3 {1.50/7 0} Rfe7 {(Rg7) 1} 142. Nd4 {1.45/7 0} Kh7 {
(Rcd7) 2} 143. Nf3 {1.54/6 0} Rf7 {(Kg8) 1} 144. Ng5+ {2.12/8 0} Kg7 {(Kh8) 0}
145. Nxf7 {0} Kxf7 {(Rxf7) 2.16/8 0} 146. Kf1 {2.16/8 0} Kg7 {(Rd7) 0} 147. Qd4
{2.14/8 0} Kg8 {1} 148. Re1 {2.06/12 0} Kg7 {(Rg7) 1} 149. Bf3 {2.11/9 0} Kg8 {
0} 150. Ra1 {2.04/12 0} Kg7 {(Rg7) 1} 151. Ra2 {2.12/8 0} Kg8 {0} 152. Be2 {
2.04/13 0} Kg7 {(Rg7) 1} 153. Bd3 {2.05/8 0} Kg8 {0} 154. Raa4 {2.04/13 0} Kg7
{(Rg7) 0} 155. Ra1 {2.05/9 0} Kg8 {0} 156. Be2 {2.01/12 0} Kg7 {(Rg7) 0} 157.
Rc1 {2.04/8 0} Kg8 {0} 158. Rb1 {2.04/14 0} Kg7 {(Rg7) 0} 159. Rd1 {2.05/9 0}
Kg8 {0} 160. Rb1 {2.04/15 0} Kg7 {(Rg7) 0} 161. Rc1 {0} Kg8 {2.04/10 0} 162.
Re1 {2.04/15 0} Kg7 {(Rg7) 0} 163. Rb1 {0} Kg8 {2.04/10 0} 164. Rd1 {0} Kg7 {
(Rg7) 2.04/13 0} 165. Rb1 {0} Kg8 {2.04/7 0} 166. Rd1 {2.04/13 0} Kg7 {(Rg7) 0}
167. Re1 {0} Kg8 {(Kh7) 2.04/7 0} 168. Ra1 {0} Kh7 {(Rg7) 2.01/8 0} 169. Raa4 {
0} Kg8 {2.04/8 0} 170. Ra2 {0} Kh7 {(Rg7) 2.04/15 0} 171. Bd3 {0} Kg8 {2.06/6 0
} 172. Rd2 {2.01/11 0} Kh7 {(Rg7) 0} 173. Rc2 {2.05/6 0} Kg8 {1} 174. Be2 {
2.01/12 0} Kh7 {(Rg7) 1} 175. Bf3 {2.06/6 0} Kg8 {(Rg7) 0} 176. Ra2 {2.04/9 0}
Kh7 {(Rg7) 0} 177. Rc2 {2.04/7 0} Kg8 {(Rg7) 0} 178. Ra2 {2.04/10 0} Kh7 {
(Rg7) 0} 179. Be2 {2.04/8 0} Kg8 {0} 180. Raa4 {2.01/13 0} Kh7 {(Rh7) 0} 181.
Ra1 {2.04/8 0} Kg8 {0} 182. Bf3 {2.04/13 0} Kh7 {(Rg7) 0} 183. Rc1 {2.06/7 0}
Kg8 {(Rg7) 0} 184. Rd1 {2.09/6 0} Kh7 {1} 185. Rc1 {2.06/12 0} Kg8 {(Rg7) 0}
186. Rc2 {2.13/6 0} Kh7 {(Rg7) 0} 187. Rd2 {2.12/8 0} Kg8 {(Rg7) 0} 188. Rc2 {
2.13/6 0} Kh7 {(Rg7) 0} 189. Rb2 {2.12/7 0} Kg8 {(Rg7) 0} 190. Be2 {2.12/6 0}
Kh7 {(Rg7) 0} 191. Rc2 {2.15/6 0} Kg8 {(Rg7) 0} 192. Rd2 {2.11/7 0} Kh7 {
(Rg7) 0} 193. Ra4 {1.93/7 0} Kg8 {(Rg7) 0} 194. Ra1 {1.93/5 0} Kh7 {(Qd8) 0}
195. b4 {1.97/6 0} Kg8 {(Rg7) 0} 196. Bf3 {1.96/6 0} Kh7 {(Rd7) 0} 197. Rad1 {
1.96/5 0} Kg8 {(Rd7) 0} 198. Rf2 {1.97/6 0} Kh7 {(Rd7) 0} 199. Rb2 {1.93/6 0}
Kg8 {(Rd7) 0} 200. Rc1 {0} Kh7 {(Rd7) 1.91/8 0} 201. Rd2 {0} Kg8 {
(Rd7) 1.90/7 0} 202. Rcd1 {0} Kh7 {(Rd7) 1.91/7 0} 203. Ra1 {0} Kg8 {
(Rd7) 1.91/8 0} 204. Raa2 {0} Kh7 {(Rd7) 1.92/7 0} 205. Rg2 {0} Kg8 {
(Rg7) 1.95/5 0} 206. Rac2 {0} Kh7 {(Rd7) 1.95/6 0} 207. Rc1 {0} Kg8 {
(Rd7) 1.90/6 0} 208. Rf2 {0} Kh7 {(Rd7) 1.90/7 0} 209. Rfc2 {0} Kg8 {
(Rd7) 1.90/7 0} 210. Rb1 {0} Kh7 {(Rd7) 1.90/7 0} 211. Be2 {0} Kg8 {
(Rd7) 1.87/8 0} 212. Rcc1 {1.92/6 0} Kh7 {(Rd7) 0} 213. Rd1 {1.89/7 0} Kg8 {
(Rd7) 0} 214. Rbc1 {1.88/7 0} Kh7 {(Rd7) 0} 215. Rb1 {0} Kg8 {(Rd7) 1.90/7 0}
216. Rb3 {0} Kh7 {(Rd7) 1.91/7 0} 217. Bf3 {0} Kg8 {(Rd7) 1.90/7 0} 218. Rb2 {
1.88/7 0} Kh7 {(Rd7) 0} 219. Be2 {1.88/6 0} Kg8 {(Rd7) 1} 220. Bd3 {1.88/7 0}
Rg7 {(Rd7) 1} 221. Rc2 {1.87/7 0} Kh7 {(Rd7) 0} 222. Rdd2 {1.92/6 0} Nd7 {
(Qd7) 1} 223. Rd1 {1.87/6 0} Nb8 {(Bf7) 0} 224. Rcd2 {1.94/5 0} Kg8 {(Qd7) 0}
225. Rg2 {0} Kh7 {(Nd7) 1.90/6 0} 226. Rb2 {1.87/7 0} Kg8 {(Nd7) 1} 227. Rdb1 {
1.91/6 0} Kh7 {0} 228. Be2 {1.87/13 0} Qc7 {(Nd7) 0} 229. Rc2 {1.91/7 0} Qc8 {
(Nd7) 0} 230. Bf3 {1.90/8 0} Qc7 {(Nd7) 0} 231. Ra1 {1.95/6 0} Qc8 {(Nd7) 0}
232. Rd1 {1.90/7 0} Qd7 {(Nd7) 0} 233. Rdd2 {1.99/6 0} Qc7 {(Qd8) 0} 234. Rh2 {
1.93/6 0} Qc8 {(Nd7) 0} 235. Rhf2 {1.95/5 0} Qc7 {(Qd7) 0} 236. Ra2 {1.93/6 0}
Qc8 {(Nd7) 0} 237. Rac2 {1.98/6 0} Qc7 {(Qd7) 0} 238. Ra2 {1.93/6 0} Qc8 {
(Nd7) 0} 239. Rae2 {1.93/6 0} Qc7 {(Nd7) 0} 240. Rc2 {1.93/6 0} Qc8 {(Nd7) 0}
241. Rb2 {1.95/5 0} Qc7 {(Qd7) 0} 242. Rbc2 {1.93/6 0} Qc8 {(Nd7) 0} 243. Rb2 {
1.17/5 0} Qc7 {(Qd7) 0} 244. Bg2 {1.18/6 0} Qc8 {(Qe7) 0} 245. e4 {1.19/7 0}
fxe4 {' 2} 246. Bh3 {1.13/12 0} Rf7 {(Bf7) 1} 247. Rbc2 {1.18/7 0} Rf5 {(Qd7) 0
} 248. Bxf5 {0} exf5 {2.27/5 0} 249. Rfd2 {2.13/10 0} Qe6 {(Bf7) 1} 250. Ke1 {
2.26/5 0} Bf7 {0} 251. Rd1 {1.75/10 0} Kh6 {0} 252. Kd2 {2.20/6 0} Kh7 {(Nd7) 0
} 253. Kc1 {0} Kh6 {(Nd7) 2.10/7 0} 254. Kb1 {2.23/6 0} Kh7 {0} 255. Rcc1 {
1.78/9 0} Kh6 {1} 256. Kb2 {2.20/6 0} Kh7 {0} 257. Re1 {2.15/6 0} Kg8 {(Nd7) 0}
258. Rc2 {2.20/6 0} Kf8 {(Qe7) 0} 259. Rd1 {2.26/5 0} Ke8 {(Kg8) 0} 260. Rc3 {
2.28/5 0} Kd8 {0} 261. Rc2 {2.18/5 0} Kc7 {(Kc8) 0} 262. Rc3 {2.14/4 0} Kc8 {0}
263. Rd2 {2.04/6 0} Nd7 {1} 264. Ka3 {1.58/9 0} Kb8 {0} 265. Rb2 {1.61/6 0} Ka8
{0} 266. Rcc2 {. 1.75/6 0} Nb8 {1} 267. Ka2 {2.00/7 0} Qe7 {(Nd7) 1} 268. Rc1 {
0} Qe6 {Time (Lag: Av=0.64s, max=2.3s) 1.74/6 0} 0-1

kn6/1p3b2/p1p1q1p1/P1PpPp1p/1P1QpP1P/6P1/KR6/2R5 w - - 0 269